Face the Challenge
Developing the multi-cultural organisation: managing diversity or respecting differences?
Today's business and service organisations face a three-fold challenge. With management and employees of a variety of national and cultural backgrounds, they must:
1 enable this heterogeneous workforce to work together harmoniously toward their common goals;
2 maximise the contribution of each member of what is in fact a large team;
3 ensure fair treatment for all, irrespective of background.
Meeting this challenge demands systematic efforts on the part of these organisations, as many of them have come to realise. Whether the multi-cultural character of the company arises from its internationally mobile workforce and its local operations in various countries, or from the mixed backgrounds of a workforce in a single location, the organisation must address this diversity if it is to be successful.
DEFENSIVE OR DEVELOPMENTAL?
Every organisation has a strategic choice to make in how it will face this issue, between a fundamentally defensive approach, and one that is developmental in nature and effect.
An organisation which adopts the defensive approach treats cultural differences as hazards - a series of weak links between people in which there is great potential for misunderstanding, conflict, mistrust and even resentment. It assumes at the start that certain people are inherently culturally insensitive to others. Handling 'cultural diversity' therefore means avoiding giving offence to groups or individuals, preventing harassment, and managing grievances. It may have an implicit political objective as well, to reduce the alleged dominance of one 'culture' or another.
The developmental approach, on the other hand, first of all sees cultural differences for what they are - potentially different values, assumptions, expectations, and behaviour which people bring to business as a result of their differing backgrounds. As expressed by one prominent writer in the field, culture is "the way in which a group of people solves problems" (Trompenaars). Moreover, the developmental approach recognises that these collective tendencies reveal themselves as individual differences. Members of a team are not there to represent a 'culture' or particular ethnic group - they represent themselves.
ACKNOWLEDGING THE DIFFERENCE
In this way, handling cultural differences means recognising
1 that these differences can have a significant impact on how people of different national or ethnic backgrounds approach the day-to-day issues of business and professional life, and
2 that people want those differences, where they exist, to be acknowledged. The developmental approach begins with the more positive assumption that while people may sometimes be unaware of these differences, they are not automatically insensitive to them.
The outcome of the developmental approach is a recognition of these different perspectives as alternative ways of handling particular situations. Cultural differences are no longer hazards - they are opportunities to strengthen the organisation through shared learning, better communication, and new perspectives.
How can one tell whether an organisation has adopted the defensive or the developmental approach? After all, any organisation can use terms such as 'diversity,' 'culture,' 'differences,' or even 'inclusiveness' to its general goals in this area, whatever the reality.
For a start, the defensive approach often arises as a reaction to grievances or conflicts. The organisation may define it through policies, procedures, and public relations statements, and make it visible through initiatives and 'programmes.' 'Training' is preoccupied with reducing insensitivity, often by trying to induce certain subjects to admit how insensitive they are. To the extent that such efforts are presented positively (or in the words of one company's website, "leverage[d] for competitive advantage"), it is as a question of equal employment opportunity.
THE RIGHT ROUTE
Farnham Castle helps its clients follow a developmental route, which assumes a very different form. It often starts at a local level, on a practical basis, with an individual's or a team's efforts to improve the way people work together, or to prepare for wider international responsibilities. It tends not to be fixed in policy or procedure, but instead is most often driven by business needs and actual situations faced by people. Training is interactive, involving exchanges of impressions, experiences, and problems amongst learners. It recognises that perceived differences are as important as 'real' ones, for it is our perceptions of others that give rise to our reactions and judgements.
People learning to handle cultural differences will learn a great deal when they become aware of how they are culturally viewed by others. In addition to awareness, informational briefings increase people's knowledge of possible differences between cultures. That insight in turn helps them see how apparently 'strange' behaviour has its own cultural 'logic,' as the way in which a group of people have, as we said, solved universal problems. With increased mutual awareness and knowledge, mistrust tends to evaporate and questions of cultural 'dominance' become irrelevant.
PRACTICAL BENEFITS
The practical benefits of the developmental approach are seen in their effects on management style and on the way a team works together. 'Cultural' differences are now seen as individual differences arising out of people's backgrounds. These various points of view, openly communicated, represent alternatives and choices available to the group for consideration and negotiation. A greater willingness to talk directly about differences helps build trust, facilitates decision-making and opens the way, where appropriate, to compromise.
The developmental approach, as we have labelled it, needs sound leadership if it is to take root. It will be nourished by the resources of an organisation such as Farnham Castle, which is able to offer (1) collaborative training to raise awareness and increase knowledge, (2) extensive expertise in various business cultures and in the challenges and goals of international business. The developmental approach is further enhanced by training that strengthens the skills required to handle difficult situations and to communicate effectively in intercultural settings.
DIVERSITY TRULY VALUED
None of this, of course, is to imply that organisations should not concern themselves with the indispensable goals of providing a working environment that is free of 'harassment' and discrimination, and of ensuring equal career opportunities for all. We would simply say, however, that truly 'valuing diversity' means valuing the contributions that 'diverse' individuals can make. A developmental, rather than a purely defensive, approach to dealing with cultural differences will help make that a reality.
Article by Robert Day, a senior consultant for Farnham Castle specialising in effective communication/negotiation, team development, and cross-cultural issues in international business.
No comments:
Post a Comment